Paula is obligated to adhere to agency policy but should not allow agency procedures to interfere with her ethical practice of social work NASW Code of Ethics,Sections 3. The dilemma regarding justice is whether Claudia should disclose this information for the good of society, weighing this up against the harm it may do to the client.
Of most relevance is an analysis of the ethical dilemma from a teleological perspective taking the utilitarian approach where the greatest good for the greatest number of people is valued.
He is minoring in Spanish. If I seek supervision, will I be happy with the results? The ethical theory of teleology is focused on the outcomes of decisions.
However, the individual believes he is entitled to take his earned time and additional time off without pay. Paula must attempt to provide for the well-being of both Rita and Stella, even though the interests of each client conflict. Rita and her adoptive family Possible Benefits Rita will benefit from an ongoing relationship with her biological mother, preventing possible future tension and Ethical dilemma analysis about her biological family.
At first, Rhonda feels uncomfortable talking in this way about people she is close to; but then she decides it does no real harm, and she feels no remorse for joining in. This last option would be least desirable since the girl would likely be angry and upset that the nurse went behind her back and broke her promise to her.
A second alternative would be to involve social services to help with counseling, to be a support and a presence in addition to the nurse, while the parents are told. Paula will have peace of mind in the fact that she firmly believes that Stella will not relapse again if the recent relapse is not reported and the greatest good will be provided for all clients.
The person in the process. Neither keeping the promise to the girl, nor breaking it, is ideal. Essay This essay has been submitted by a student. An office worker has had a record of frequent absence. Careful thought had to be put into how to council this client, how to come up with a counseling plan that would be effective and include past and current issues.
The possibility that this could happen while Stella is taking care of Rita is too great of a risk to take. To achieve this, choices and activities must meet, as well as they can.
Paula wants to help Stella move forward while also assuring the safety and interests of the child. National Association of Social Workers. This agreement will allow Stella to have unsupervised visits with Rita once a month. Stella will not learn to take responsibility for her actions. All parties are satisfied with this arrangement.
Life does not accompany an assurance that great expectations, diligent work, creative ability, and far-sightedness will transform every single good difficulty into glad results that fulfill the ethical cases of all gatherings.
We will write a custom essay sample on Ethical Dilemma Analysis or any similar topic specifically for you Do Not Waste HIRE WRITER Using the 6-step process of ethical decision-making from Purtilo and Doherty as a guide, this paper will also explain the process of how a breach in confidentiality can still elicit the ultimate goal of ethical practice: Ethical dilemma examples Part I.
Possible Harms Stella will feel betrayed by Paula and may have difficulty trusting any social worker in the future. One possible alternative to not telling the parents is to allow the girl to leave, and think about it, give her information to review, and elicit a promise to return to discuss with the nurse any questions or concerns.
Paula is obligated to protect client confidentiality, but is also obligated to disclose information that puts a child at risk. Diverse views are shared and presented, and the best possible path is chosen. The first option Claudia discusses with her supervisor is to continue the treatment and tell Graham that the information does not need to go further as the incident was a long way in the past and no good could come from raising it again.
Limitations of ethics committees is the time needed to come to a decision since ethical dilemmas often need to be made quickly. Responding to young people disclosing sexual assault: The report should be approximately 2 pages accompanied by a 2-minute oral presentation, using VoiceThread or a PowerPoint narrated slide show.
However, it is very possible that Stella has relapsed in the past, but only told Paula of this particular occurrence because it forced her to miss work and she knew Paula would question her about her absence. Different arguments sound convincing to different people.
The client is now left feeling distraught and depressed. Step 6 is evaluation and reflection of the chosen decision. The courts will decide the legality of her action, but what of the morality? As a result, it becomes possible to view the scenario from the full picture.The more novel and difficult the ethical choice we face, the more we need to rely on discussion and dialogue with others about the dilemma.
Only by careful exploration of the problem, aided by the insights and different perspectives of others, can we make good ethical choices in such situations.
Ethical Dilemmas: Analysis of ethical case scenario An ethical dilemma can be defined as a situation where there is only a decision which is “’more right’ than the alternatives” (Hill, Glaser, & Harden,p).
Of most relevance is an analysis of the ethical dilemma from a. Analysis of an Ethical Dilemma Analysis of an Ethical Dilemma Part Two NRSV Ethical Decision Making in Health Care Grand Canyon University Today’s world is filled with endless controversial arguments, ethical debates, and a constant clashing of varying perspectives and outlooks.
ETHICAL DILEMMA ANALYSIS (GROUPS) 2 Ethical Dilemma Analysis I believe the most problematic ethical dilemma is the airline pilot and the most ethical response for the airline pilot’s doctor would be to tell the company about his condition because it could not only harm him but also the general public.
The nurse that promised confidentiality now faces an ethical dilemma: if she keeps her promise to the girl, she may not get the proper follow up care and support to treat her illness, and if she breaks her promise, she has violated the ethical principles of fidelity, and autonomy (Nathanson, ).
ETHICAL DILEMMA ANALYSIS (GROUPS) 2 Ethical dilemma analysis (groups) I believe the most problematic ethical dilemma is the airline pilot and the most ethical response for the airline pilot’s doctor would be to tell the company about his condition.Download